ESCOBAR AND ASSOCIATES ANNOUCEMENT REGARDING COVID-19

Escobar and Associates Attorneys at Law remains open during the COVID-19 Coronavirus pandemic. Legal services are defined as “essential” within the Stay at Home Order executed by Florida Governor, Ron DeSantis. We remain committed to providing uninterrupted legal services to all clients. We also remain dedicated to the health and safety of our clients and staff. Within the office, our firm has already implemented protocols to keep clients and staff safe during this crisis. We understand as criminal defense attorneys how crucial it is for our attorneys and staff to remain available 24 hours a day, seven days a week to provide legal services for clients in need.

Your pursuit of justice starts here!

Speak to an attorney 24 hours a day free consultations

Email Us & Get Help
Today

The Florida “fish case” and “over-criminalization”

| Mar 11, 2015 | Criminal Defense

Sometimes the U.S. Supreme Court addresses questions of law that are of monumental significance on their face, such as when a criminal suspect must be informed of his or her legal rights upon arrest. On other occasions, however, the importance of a Court decision is not as readily apparent, and sometimes the subject of the case can, on first examination, seem unimportant or even trivial.

Consider, for example, the case that the Court decided not too long ago, Yates v. United States, in which the topic of discussion appears to have been, at least in part, whether a fish is a “document.” The case has become popularly referred to as “the fish case.”

The underlying facts involved a Florida fisherman who was accused of having caught undersize fish and was then accused of throwing some of them back into the water instead of bringing them to shore to be counted. That act led to the fisherman being accused of a violation of the Sarbanes Oxley Act, a law that federal prosecutors use to punish corporations and individuals of accounting fraud, conviction under which can lead to imprisonment for up to 20 years.

The fisherman argued at trial that the Sarbanes-Oxley Act was intended to apply to media meant to store information, like documents or computer hard drives. The jury disagreed, and convicted him. On appeal to a federal court of appeals, it agreed with the that a fish can be a “tangible object” under Sarbanes-Oxley.

The Supreme Court reversed the court of appeals, agreeing with Yates’ interpretation and remanding the case back to the trial court.

The real significance of the case, though, is that for the first time the Court referred to “over-criminalization” in the body of one of its opinions. That is, the prosecution’s attempt to prosecute Yates was possibly too aggressive and relied on stretching the law’s definition, threatening Yates with a potentially disproportionate punishment given the nature of his claimed offense.

Over-criminalization has been a complaint of some in the legal defense community who are concerned with both federal and state prosecutions that may be overzealous, and criminal laws that are written too broadly. For the U.S. Supreme Court to use the term for the first time suggests that the arguments of these individuals may finally be making some headway in the judicial system.

  • Martindale-Hubbell | Top rated lawyer in Tampa | Richard Escobar | For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability | Martindale-Hubbell Top rated lawyer
  • Top Lawyers 2016 | Richard Escobar
  • Top Lawyers 2016 | Dino Michaels
  • Highest Possible Rating in Both Legal Ability & Ethical Standards | AV |AV Preeminent | Richard Escobar | 2016
  • Judicial Education | AV | AV Preeminent | Richard Escobar | 2016
  • CLIENT | DISTINCTION AWARD | Dino mike Michaels, Esq. | Recognized for Excellence | Quality of Service | Overall Value | Responsiveness | Communication Ability
  • 15 | YEAR | Anniversary | Proudly Serving | the Community | Since 2001 | Dino Mike Michaels
  • 10 Best 2018 | Richard Escobar | Client Satisfaction | American Institute Of Criminal Law Attorneys

Archives

Email Us & Get Help
Today

FindLaw Network